Disposable email, alias or your real address?

Last updated 5 November 2026

The best first question is simple: will you ever need this account again? If you will, a disposable address is probably the wrong choice.

How the three options compare

Disposable addressEmail aliasYour real address
How it worksA short-lived inbox on a web pageA separate address that forwards to your main inboxYour normal inbox
Signup neededUsually noYes, with an alias providerYou already have it
Can you still get mail later?Only while you keep access, and old mail is deletedYes, until you turn the alias offYes
Can you stop the mail?Yes, by abandoning itYes, by turning off that one aliasOnly by unsubscribing or filtering
Can you reply?Often not, and never on MaillyDepends on the providerYes
Account recoveryUnreliableWorks while the alias is activeWorks

Providers vary, so check the details of the one you choose.

When each one fits

Use a disposable address when you need one email once and won't miss the account. Examples are a one-off download, a newsletter you want to read once, or a trial of a tool you probably won't return to.

Use an alias when you want to keep the account but not hand out your main address. Examples are shops, forums and subscriptions. Options include Firefox Relay and SimpleLogin. Some email providers also let you add a tag to your address, but that usually leaves your real address visible.

Use your real address for anything you'd struggle to replace. That includes banking, government services, health, work, school and the accounts you use to sign in to other services.

The catch with disposable addresses

A disposable address can work fine at signup and cause problems later. If a service asks you to confirm your email to sign in or reset a password, the message goes to an inbox you may no longer be able to open. On Mailly, losing the browser key means losing that inbox for good.

Some services also don't allow disposable addresses. Check their rules first. Mailly's terms don't allow using it to get around verification on those services.

Where Mailly fits

Mailly only offers disposable addresses. It doesn't forward mail to another inbox, so it isn't an alias service. If you need one email and don't expect to come back, it fits. If you're not sure, use an alias.